Tuesday

Have This Heart (2026)



Landfall Review Online

A Ball-Ache of a Thing


Lawrence Patchett. Have This Heart. ISBN 978-1-77692-304-5. Wellington: Te Herenga Waka University Press, 2026. 208 pp. RRP: $38.00.


Lawrence Patchett: Have This Heart (2026)


Whether training a rescue dog, starting a bucket chain to put out a raging fire, raising a marquee beside a line of Ferraris, or reporting on a sensitive workplace accident, then men in Have This Heart are striving for more. They care about their work, even one no one else does, because they know what the consequences will be if they don’t.
According to the back-cover blurb, Lawrence Patchett’s new story collection is “about men who are trying to do better.” Blurbs do, admittedly, have a tendency to over-simplify. This one seems particularly inaccurate, though.

You see, that’s not at all the impression I got from the stories themselves. For a start, there’s quite a variety of genres. There are supernatural stories, stories set in the future, social realist stories – the whole gamut, really. They do all foreground men, but are they all “trying to do better”? I wouldn’t have thought so.

Take, for example, the story “Lucky”, which does a pretty expert demolition job on a rather complacent fellow named Marcus. He got promoted at the office ahead of his exact contemporary Melanie, mainly because “she never put herself forward for promotion, or didn’t know how to, or whatever.” Not because she’s a woman, of course.

After scoring himself the perfect flat, he succeeds in solving the sole fly in his ointment – finding safe parking for his brand-new Ranger – by renting a space in a new parking lot that’s just opened a few blocks away. He’s too lazy to fill in the booking form properly – “it looked like a ball-ache of a thing, with a new password to put in and confirm, and then a security link via email, and all a bit fiddly to do at work when he did actually have quite a lot to be doing.” As a result, he ends up getting a year’s free parking before the firm actually notices his payments haven’t been going through.

Funnily enough, they only pick up on it because he’s sent through so many complaints – “Unacceptable puncture hazards. Tradies parking without permission. Oh, and unhoused people” – that he finally ends up on their radar whilst querying an unjustified parking ticket.

As Marcus himself admits, none of it “sounded great when read out like that.” Marcus isn’t all bad, by any means. He has an old Dad in Dunedin whom he has to drive down and see at regular intervals (hence the flash car). He’d also like to stay friends with Melanie, only somehow their jokey relationship doesn’t work quite so well now that he is, effectively, her boss.

Condemned out of your own mouth – it’s a tried-and-true fictional technique. Jason Compson in Faulkner’s The Sound and the Fury is a classic example. Jason sees his feckless siblings as just so much irritating baggage, and feels completely justified in accepting the material success he feels to be his due. Marcus might not be at that level yet, but he’s getting there. Is there still hope for him? Maybe. In any case, the story is – to my mind – entirely successful in puncturing his self-justifying façade.

“Lucky” is one thing, but there are other, more equivocal cases in Patchett’s book: “Half-Time at the Roost,” for instance. The protagonist is a small-town journalist who likes to cover the local Rugby League games even when he’s off the clock. He’s a bit of a pest, snapping away with his camera (“I’ve got a press ID”) to the irritation of at least some of the fans:
Once a diehard growled me off the sideline, years back. ‘Get out of the way, ya dick,’ he said. ‘We didn’t come down here on our day off work to look at your effing back.’
However, on this particular occasion he’s supposed to be out on a walk with his daughter, Emmy, who’s been having a hard time of it since she went away to uni:
There were some emergency trips down to Dunedin earlier this year – with me arriving in the dark, sitting by her bed in her flat … trying too hard to help, but later learning to just wait for her to talk.
The deal was that they’d take the dog for a walk, and “this would just be a short visit to take a few photos.” But it drags on and on. He bustles around, sends her off to buy a hotdog, tries hard to resist his impulse to accompany an injured player to the hospital:
I’m not a gun at emergency, but I’m the first-aider at our own office, and not all teams have a physio, so helping to stabilize an injury … frees up the manager for their sideline work … They could use the help.
Finally, though, when he sees a “doctor or nurse – you can see it the way people part, the way she takes charge like that” – stepping in, he agrees to continue the walk. They do, after all, “have only this afternoon together, then one more day of weekend left.”

So, pillar of the community, or self-important busybody? It’s possible that the author would like us to see him as the former, but unfortunately stories have a way of developing their own momentum. Our journo is certainly well-meaning, but the fact is that talking to his daughter is a tiresome duty, whereas an afternoon at the footy is a seductive treat. He does resist it, but not with a particularly good grace.

As for the other noble activities listed in the blurb – “training a rescue dog, starting a bucket chain to put out a raging fire, raising a marquee beside a line of Ferraris, or reporting on a sensitive workplace accident” – hardly any of them could be said to be an unequivocal success.

The rescue dog in question, in the title story “Have This Heart”, is actually more of an emotional support animal for a depressive young man who almost killed a mother and her children with his drunk driving. Walking her is the only thing that gets him out of the house.

The bucket-chain organiser in the futuristic “My Turn” turns out to be quite useless at fighting fires when the moment actually arrives. It’s his wife who devises an ingenious plan to defeat the blaze while he’s still bumbling around trying to find his mate, the one he did all his planning with. At least he seems to rejoice – albeit somewhat half-heartedly – at her success.

The marquee by the line of Ferraris is a reference to a rather grim fable about a newbie on a work crew who’s thoroughly mocked by the others for not knowing what a Maserati is. He’s almost killed by a clumsy move on the narrator’s part, but everyone agrees to hush it up in the interests of “avoiding paperwork”. Social realism: yes – “caring about your work”: hardly.

As for “reporting on a sensitive workplace accident” – that’s the most barbed item of all. The “Newspaper Fella” of the title manages to screw up a farm worker’s prospects of future employment by reporting his accident incorrectly: as if it had been due to his own carelessness. Our protagonist ends up scribbling a hasty retraction which seems most unlikely to improve matters. He’d like to help, but given that reporting what actually happened would involve offending one of the power couples of the district, his hands are really tied. It’s more of a Chekhovian study of an essentially weak man in a ethical quandary than any kind of inspirational tale.

In a Newsroom essay about the thinking behind his previous book, The Burning River, Patchett quotes something “the short-story writer Breton Dukes said to me recently: ‘What else can I say about it? It’s all there in the story.’”

I can certainly understand Patchett’s decision to foreground men – and white men at that – in his fiction. There’s almost, now, an unspoken rule that ventriloquising a voice that isn’t yours constitutes an act of appropriation.

And I also like the idea of writing about men who “care about their work, even when no one else does, because they know what the consequences will be if they don’t”. It is indeed important that some recognition should go out to all the guys “who are supergood at their jobs but never get any credit,”, as one of the superheroes in Ben Stiller’s classic movie Mystery Men puts it at the end of their own grand adventure.

But that’s not really what Patchett has written. William Blake said of John Milton that he was “of the Devil’s party without knowing it”. I’d like to suggest that the same backhanded compliment is true of Lawrence Patchett. His men “who are trying to do better” are – for the most part – so useless and feeble that a reading contrary to the one suggested by his blurb becomes almost inevitable.

I don’t for a moment doubt his compassion for them, but whether he acknowledges it to himself or not, he can see right through them: from the self-pitying drunk driver at the beginning to the useless old uncle at the end.

He’s more of a Chekhov than a Hemingway: his true voice is ironic and satirical – and, honestly, there’s surely far more scope for that in our present state of depression and anarchy. Breton Dukes was right. It is all there in the stories.


Janneth Gil: Lawrence Patchett (Te Herenga Waka University Press)

•

(17-25/6/26)

Landfall Review Online (16/10/2026).
[Available at: https://landfallreview.com/a-ball-ache-of-a-thing/]

[1552 wds]


Landfall 1 (1947)

•



Sunday

Exit Party (2026)


NZ Listener, vol.303, no. 4471 (3-9/10/2026)


Emily St John Mandel. Exit Party. ISBN 978-1-0350-8128-8. London: Picador, 2026. 304 pp. RRP $34.99.


Emily St. John Mandel: Exit Party (2026)

Double Helix
Station Eleven author's latest skilfully entwines elements of science fiction and traditional novels.

On the one hand there’s the world we live in: a world of wars and famines, brutal racist oligarchs and their AI overlords. On the other hand, there’s the domain of virtual entertainment: Everything Everywhere All at Once, Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. The idea of overlapping universes, in particular, has become a rather facile pop-culture trope.

So what’s a bona fide novelist, a concocter of long-form fictions, to do under such circumstances? You can’t keep up. Reality is bound to anticipate your most startling inventions. You can always retrace your steps, of course: serve up some more of the same old tried-and-true material: adultery, murder, mistaken identities, stalking and bullying.

Emily St. John Mandel is probably still best known for her prescient novel Station Eleven (2014), centred on a flu-like pandemic which wiped out most of the world’s population. Written well before the advent of COVID-19, the filming of her story for a Netflix miniseries had to be shifted from Chicago to the smaller city of Mississauga in Canada to accommodate the disruptions of the actual pandemic: reality imitating art, as you might say.

So her new novel, Exit Party, has a certain weight of expectation on it. While not exactly an SF writer, she does use much of the machinery of contemporary sci-fi and cli-fi. But neither could you call her a mainstream novelist, in the traditional sense – a writer more interested in characters and their psychology than the events they participate in. Her work is really an amalgam of both approaches.

That’s not as unusual a literary stance as it might seem. As I read Exit Party, I was reminded of the heyday of High Postmodernism, when the novelist Vladimir Nabokov earned himself the cover of Time for the invention of Antiterra (or Demonia): the world parallel to our own where he set his long-anticipated late novel Ada, or Ardor: A Family Chronicle. Time’s cover art went on to proclaim that “The Novel is alive and living in Antiterra.”


TIME Magazine Cover: Vladimir Nabokov (May 23, 1969)


This was way back in 1969, when the death of the novel was being proclaimed on all sides. Tom Wolfe said it would be replaced by the New Journalism. Alain Robbe-Grillet proposed the Nouveau roman as an alternative to its outdated nineteenth-century structures. Any number of pundits predicted that it would be overtaken by visual media such as cinema and television.

Emily St. John Mandel wasn’t even born at the time. Nor does she appear to find the vocation of novelist so problematic. Like Nabokov,, she has created two worlds: both heightened versions of our own. I don’t want to say too much about them, but anyone who reads the blurb will gather that one is an accelerated version of our own fragmentations and disorder; the other the precise opposite, a world of complete control of all the citizens, all the time.

What’s the point she’s trying to make? That the same character can be a thief in one world, and a police operative in the other? Do these diverging destinies make them entirely different people? The idea of the double is a device as old as fiction itself, but that doesn’t stop us from finding them fascinating. How similar can any set of twins really be? In Edgar Allan Poe’s “William Wilson” the twin performs more as a spasm of conscience, an hallucination designed to awaken the narrator to himself. In Mark Twain’s The Prince and the Pauper the whole thing comes down to an argument over nature or nurture.

Each of Mandel’s sets of twins comes from a different reality, so each of them has a different conception of the world. More to the point, though, they seem to be inherently different – in their attitude to family, to society, to the meaning of self-fulfilment. For her, it would seem, the question of individual identity can only really be compared to a series of forks in the road – or, if you prefer, a double helix.

There are, after all, strange commonalities between the two worlds. A certain painting, Swan-Dive, portraying a wintry sea with a diver’s two feet disappearing into it, seems to obsess virtually all of the characters, through all of the ups-and-downs of their lives.

There’s a relaxed, somewhat languid quality to Mandel’s prose which somehow naturalises the bizarre mindscapes her characters are forced to inhabit. It’s not that any of them are particularly interesting or attractive, but they are – for the most part, at least – very believable.

And the issues she’s interested in examining are very much those of traditional, old-fashioned fiction: Is raising children more important than pursuing your career? Can you do both satisfactorily? Is there such a thing as a justifiable murder? It would really be easier to pair her with George Eliot or Virginia Woolf than with J. G. Ballard or John Barth.

Mandel’s book keeps folding back on itself to examine these questions from multiple angles, with overlapping narrators, and constantly shifting time-scales. It’s not until the very end of the novel that the deeper significance of its opening, the post-curfew party in Los Angeles which serves as a kind of focal point for the action, begins to come clear.

I have to say that I was left with more questions than answers: not so much about the merits of the book – it’s clearly a very accomplished, readable novel – as about the philosophical issues Mandel raises. She’s a naturally gifted storyteller but I’d actually see her as more of a metaphysician by nature.

The painting Swan Dive operates, in the end, as almost the only stable ground in all of these worlds, physical, intellectual and aesthetic. If I stop to ask myself about it, then I have to admit that it’s hard for me to express just exactly what it means – the last signs of the individual in a turbulent, storm-driven cosmos, perhaps? On the other hand, if I don’t try too hard to confine it to just one meaning, its importance seems perfectly clear.




Listener Reviews: Station Eleven’s Emily St John Mandel’s new novel arrives (29/9/2026)

(3-7/9/2026)

NZ Listener, vol.303, no. 4471 (3-9/10/2026): 38-39.

[998 wds]

Emily St. John Mandel (2017)


•




Friday

Riemke Ensing Tribute (2026)



NZ Poetry Shelf

Paula Green:
Poetry Shelf pays tribute:
Riemke Ensing (1939 – 2026)

Love Affair

A given poem from Katherine Mansfield


You wrote the table
was laid
for two
but nobody came
so you dined opposite
a white napkin.

It’s called giving yourself
to life.
Through the window
a quiet branch
has the evening
to itself
also.

- Riemke Ensing
from Classic NZ Poets in Performance (2006)

“Jack, you’ve got so fat!” True, perhaps, but not exactly tactful. But then, Riemke’s sense of humour tended to prevail over the Kiwi convention of backbiting people in private rather than to their faces. I have to respect her for that. I felt, too, that keeping things jokey was her way of combatting a certain turn towards melancholy. It’s all there in the poems. Poetry was a necessity, not a luxury, for Riemke. How else could she make sense of her life in this strange country at the bottom of the world, with these people whose monosyllabic utterances were so difficult to fathom? I remember at the launch of Classic New Zealand Poets in Performance, Riemke came upon my parents and me sitting out in the corridor, munching on sandwiches, because my Mum was sure that my Dad would get irritable if he didn’t get his dinner on time. She laughed out loud at how absurd we looked. Then she accepted the offer of a sandwich and sat down with us to polish it off. That was Riemke: vital, outrageous, but also, in the final analysis, quite practical – as well (of course) as fiercely intelligent. She scared me, but I’ll miss her anyway.


(14/8/26)

'Poetry Shelf pays tribute: Riemke Ensing (1939 – 2026).' Ed. Paula Green.
NZ Poetry Shelf: a poetry page with reviews, interviews, and other things.
[Available at: https://nzpoetryshelf.com/2026/09/04/poetry-shelf-pays-tribute-riemke-ensing-1939-1926/] (4/9/26)

[203 wds]


Poetry Box: Paula Green


•